What do you mean when say that something is a dumb mistake? Usually it means that someone took action without thinking it through, and that usually means that they did an easy thing instead of a more difficult, more consciously driven, thing. And that often happens when people oversimplify context and then generalize it.
Here’s a typically dumb way to use NLP. Stand on one side of the stage when you want the audience to feel something. Stand on the other side when you want them to feel something different. Some schools will teach this as if it is an important training technique.
Let’s break it down: this works if you are clear about what you want the audience to feel, can elicit a deep enough emotion to anchor it, and avoid muddying the anchor with any other thoughts or feelings. In other words, it is most likely to work under conditions that are unlikely to occur in real life.
What’s a smarter way to use NLP anchoring? Do you know what a motif is? It’s a repeated phrase, image or element that occurs at different times throughout a work of art. Whenever it occurs, it brings back the idea or emotion that has been tied to it once and then built up through recurrences.
You can create a motif and practice it as you prepare a conversation or presentation. Or you can recognize a moment of genuine emotion, and then bring it back into the same conversation or presentation periodically to retrieve the emotion. A motif, in NLP terms, is an anchor. And like most anchoring, it works best when it takes advantage of one strong moment and creates echoes of that moment across different frames.
It’s dumb to think that you can use an NLP technique in real life exactly as you used it in a classroom. In the classroom, conditions and boundaries were set to help direct attention. In a word that is becoming increasingly popular, the technique was situated. That means that it depended on context to work the way it worked.
We do this to help people learn. Once they have learned, they need to practice working in a way that is responsive to the different situations in which they find themselves.
NLP is dumb when it is used without reference to context. You need to read the room, and then respond to what you read. There is no way to have influence without paying attention.